Bci letter regarding law college semester arrear exam full letter 3 pages

[11/2, 08:04] Sekarreporter 1: Press Release dated 01.11.2020
The General Council of the Bar Council of India has considered the
Order dated 21.10.2020 passed by the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi in
W. P. (C) No.8307/2020 titled as Samarth Nayar & Ors. Vs. Controller
of Examinations, Guru Gobind Singh Indraprastha University & Ors.
A perusal of Para-9 of the above referred Order reveals that the
respondent No.1 (Controller of Examinations, Guru Gobind Singh
Indraprastha University) has clarified that the students pursuing law
degrees who have approached the court by filing of the present petition
would be free, not to take the physical exam, which are being held from
It has been further stated by the Respondent No.1 “(Controller of
Examinations, Guru Gobind Singh Indraprastha University) in the said para
that the Students who do not wish to take the said exams may not give the
exam on 02.11.2020 without any penal consequences. Such students would be
allowed to give subsequent Re-appear exams which will be held once the
colleges start functioning properly”.
In Para-10 of the said Order, the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi had held
“keeping in view the above stand of respondent No.1 and in view of the
clarification that no penal consequences will follow on the petitioners, choice is
left to the petitioners. If they wish to give the exam commencing on 02.11.2020
they are free to do so. If for some reason they do not feel appropriate to give the
said exam they will be free to appear in the Reappear exam which will be held
It is observed by the Council, that if physical exams as contemplated by
the University is held with effect from 02.11.2020 and if the said exams
are held without any penal consequences to any Student who is unable
to appear in the said exam, no student shall be prejudiced or affected
and they will get an opportunity to appear in the Exam again after
physical reopening of the college/university as contemplated in the
Circular/Press Release of the Bar Council of India dated 27.05.2020 and
09.06.2020 respectively, which was further clarified by the BCI
Resolution dated 05.10.2020.
[11/2, 08:04] Sekarreporter 1: Furthermore, the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India vide its Judgment
dated 28.08.2020 in Writ Petition (Civil) No.724/2020, 739/2020,
746/2020, 745/2020, 741/2020, 794/2020, 814/2020, 862/2020, 861/2020
and Special Leave Petition (C) No.10042/2020 (Diary No. 15056/2020)
has clearly given a right to respective State Disaster Management
Authority in view of the pandemic to make requests to the concerned
authorities for postponing the physical exam if they deem fit, which
request will have to be heard by the authority concerned.
Accordingly, Council, hereby modifies BCI’s
Resolution/Circular/Press Release dated 27.05.2020, 09.06.2020, and
05.10.2020 to provide an option to Universities/Centres of Legal
Education to conduct physical examination with the NOC of the State
Government and State Disaster Management Authority, by giving the
option to such law students who are unable and/or unwilling to appear
in such physical exams till the Covid-19 pandemic is averted, and
having appeared therein, who are/is unable to clear such exam, to
appear in the re-appear exam after physical reopening of the
University/Centres of Legal Education.
The council further places on record the fact that the resolution dated
27.05.2020, later on clarified by Press note dated 09.06.2020 and
resolution of 05.10.2020 respectively, was passed believing that the
pandemic Covid-19 will subside sooner than later. However, the
pandemic still persists with no early respite from it in sight. The
Council, therefore, resolves that examination for all intermediary along
with final year law students/classes too may be held online, if
Universities/Law Colleges are able to hold it online, and if adequate
infrastructure and other facilities for students is/are available. It is
further resolved that if online exam is so conducted and any
student/students is/are unable to take it, or having appeared therein, is
unable to pass such exam/subject paper, such students shall be entitled
to take the reappear exam/paper whenever it is held preferably within
one month of physical re-opening of the Universities/College after the
pandemic is averted.
This would leave no cause of grievance to any candidate and this
recourse will reduce the anxiety of the candidates as it would provide
such candidates who are averse to take the physical exam during the
pandemic Covid-19, with an option to take the exam on a later date
within one month of physical reopening of Law Colleges/Universities
when normalcy resumes and when the pandemic situation no longer
exists, and/or an option to also appear in online exams presently, if the
University/Center of Legal Education is able to conduct such online
examination, if they i.e. students are comfortable with it, while, if, any
candidate is unable or unwilling to appear in the online exam owing to
technical and/or infrastructural difficulties or otherwise, and is also
averse to appear in any physical exam which may be held during the
pandemic period owing to apprehension of getting infected with
[11/2, 08:05] Sekarreporter 1: Covid-19, or having appeared therein is unable to pass such
offline/online exam/s, they can always appear in such physical exam
after the pandemic is over without being penalized or prejudiced.
Furthermore, as has been stated in our previous Circular/Press Release,
all students affected by pandemic who are promoted to the next
year/semester, without their promotion getting affected, and who are
unable to appear in or having appeared is/are unable to clear any
presently held (during pandemic) offline/online exam and/or the
physical exam to be preferably held within one month of physical re-
opening of Universities/Colleges, shall also be provided with
opportunity to clear such papers, before the grant of law degree,
immediately, after the final year examination, without any penalization
or prejudice being caused to them.
In view of the above discussion and observation, the resolution dated
27.05.2020 and the clarification issued by the Bar Council of India on
09.06.2020 and 05.10.2020 stand modified accordingly.
(Srimanto Sen)
Bar Council of India


You may also like...