Plea to remove Governor not maintainable, says High Court
NEWS
CITIES
CHENNAI
CHENNAI
Plea to remove Governor not maintainable, says High Court
Legal CorrespondentCHENNAI , JANUARY 04, 2020 01:20 ISTUPDATED: JANUARY 04, 2020 01:20 IST
Issue relates to release of convicts in the Prime Minister Rajiv Gandhi assassination case
The Madras High Court on Friday held as not maintainable a public interest litigation petition seeking a direction to the Centre to remove Governor Banwarilal Purohit for not taking a decision on State Cabinet’s September 2018 recommendation to release all seven convicts involved in former Prime Minister Rajiv Gandhi assassination case.
Justices M. Sathyanarayanan and R. Hemalatha dismissed the petition filed by M. Kannadasan of Thanthai Periyar Dravidar Kazhagam, on the ground that a court of law was not empowered to issue such a direction when the Constitution states that a Governor shall hold office during the pleasure of the President.
The judges pointed out that Article 156 lays down the term of office of Governor. The provision states that a Governor would hold office during the pleasure of the President or until he/she resigns his post though the tenure as such for those holding the constitutional post would be for five years or until a successor enters the office. The Bench recorded that the PIL petitioner had insisted upon the removal of the Governor on grounds of arbitrariness, mala fide and partisan attitude, on the issue of releasing the seven convicts, “for the reason that he was a member of a particular political party [before assuming office] and a sympathiser of an organisation.”
The judges recalled the Supreme Court verdict in the B.P. Singhal versus Union of India (2010) said: “A Governor is neither an employee nor an agent of the Union Government… Like the President, Governors are expected to be apolitical, discharging purely constitutional functions, irrespective of their earlier political background.
“Governors cannot be politically active. Reputed elder statesmen, able administrators and eminent personalities with maturity and experience are expected to be appointed as Governors. While some of them may come from a political background, once they are appointed as Governors, they owe their allegiance and loyalty to the Constitution and not to any political party.”
The apex court went on to state: “A Governor cannot be removed on the ground that he is out of sync with the policies and ideologies of the Union Government or the party in power at the Centre. Governors need not be in sync with the policies of the Union Government. They are not required to subscribe to the ideology of the party in power at the Centre.”
In the same judgment, it was also held that judicial review of withdrawal of pleasure was limited in the case of a Governor and that only when a prima facie case of arbitrariness of mala fide was made out, could the court require the Centre to produce materials to satisfy itself that the withdrawal of pleasure was for good and compelling reasons.
Promoted
2/3 BHK homes Off Sarjapur Rd, Pay 2.5% to Book your Dream home Valid Till 31st JANAssetz Property|Sponsored
Further, when S. Nalini, one of the seven convicts, filed a writ petition in the High Court last year seeking a direction to the Governor to accept the Cabinet recommendation and order her release from prison, a Division Bench of Justices R. Subbiah and C. Saravanan had held that no such direction could be issued to the Governor.
That Bench had held that Article 361 of the Constitution insulates the Governor from being questioned or made answerable before any court with respect to discharge of his duties. Therefore, the present plea seeking a direction to the Centre to remove Mr. Purohit from office could not be entertained, the Bench led by Justice Sathyanarayanan said.
Why you should pay for quality journalism –Click to know more
Comments
Related TopicsChennai
Recommended for you
Kavalan app: personal safety at a click, but what about data?
Doctors mimic brain signals to spinal cord; help boy get back on his feet
Singaperumal Temple tank filled with garbage, residents say
Reconsider closure of Krishna Gate, VCK chief tells IIT
Homebuyer awarded ₹5.30 lakh compensation
Woman chokes to death while eating bajji in Chennai
Man pushed off moving train; four, including wife, held
Fog blankets Chennai, flights delayed due to poor visibility
No power supply
Cancer Institute organises memorial oration
Kavalan app: personal safety at a click, but what about data?
Doctors mimic brain signals to spinal cord; help boy get back on his feet
Singaperumal Temple tank filled with garbage, residents say
Reconsider closure of Krishna Gate, VCK chief tells IIT
Homebuyer awarded ₹5.30 lakh compensation
Woman chokes to death while eating bajji in Chennai
Man pushed off moving train; four, including wife, held
Fog blankets Chennai, flights delayed due to poor visibility
No power supply
Cancer Institute organises memorial oration
Kavalan app: personal safety at a click, but what about data?
1 / 10
Previous StoryCancer Institute organises memorial oration
Next Story Police chief fabricating stories, says activist
Cadbury Wants Your Recipe For Its Next ChocolateCadbury Dairy Milk|Sponsored
Spacious 2 BHK Homes Rs 65.30L Off Sarjapur Road By Assetz 63 east Tower DAssetz Property|Sponsored
3 BHK Modern homes @ Rs95L Near Manyata Tech Park By AssetzAssetz Property|Sponsored
Check your Credit Score Here Now For Free!Paisabazaar|Sponsored
2,3 & 4 BHK Elite Luxury Homes near Manyata Tech Park,BangalorePuravankara|Sponsored
Ireland PM visits his father’s village in Maharashtra, to celebrate New Year in GoaThe visit was a “special moment” as three generations of his family had gathered, he said after the villagers felicitated him.The Hindu
Comments will be moderated by The Hindu editorial team.
Comments that are abusive, personal, incendiary or irrelevant cannot be published.
Please write complete sentences. Do not type comments in all capital letters, or in all lower case letters, or using abbreviated text. (example: u cannot substitute for you, d is not ‘the’, n is not ‘and’).
We may remove hyperlinks within comments.
Please use a genuine email ID and provide your name, to avoid rejection.
TRENDING TODAYTHE HINDU EXPLAINS
FACT CHECK
CITIZENSHIP AMENDMENT ACT
CRICKET
