Setting aside a Madras high court madurai bench order that had directed further investigation in a 2013 murder case, despite no valid justification for delaying the trial, the top court warned that courts must act swiftly to curb any attempts by parties to prolong cases without legitimate grounds.
Denial of speedy, timely justice disastrous to rule of law: SC
By
Utkarsh Anand
, New Delhi
Oct 02, 2024 06:42 AM IST
The top court warned that courts must act swiftly to curb any attempts by parties to prolong cases without legitimate grounds.
The Supreme Court has underscored that the denial of speedy and timely justice can be “disastrous to the rule of law”, while stressing the need for courts to impose exemplary costs on frivolous proceedings to prevent parties from exploiting legal processes.
A view of Supreme Court of India in New Delhi. (Hindustan Times)
A view of Supreme Court of India in New Delhi. (Hindustan Times)
“Denial of speedy and timely justice can be disastrous to rule of law in the long term. Even if the parties involved in a case themselves, with no valid justification attempt to delay the proceedings, the courts need to be vigilant and nip any such attempt in the bud instantly. The administration of justice feeds on the faith of the citizenry and nothing should be done to even remotely shake that faith and confidence,” said a bench of justices Bhushan R Gavai and KV Viswanathan in a judgment on Monday.
Get Unlimited access to Hindustan Times E-paper and Archives at 1199/- per year
Setting aside a Madras high court order that had directed further investigation in a 2013 murder case, despite no valid justification for delaying the trial, the top court warned that courts must act swiftly to curb any attempts by parties to prolong cases without legitimate grounds.
Promoted
Bengaluru court orders FIR against Nirmala Sitharaman in electoral bond case, CM Siddaramaiah calls for her resignation
Hindustan Times
Aishwarya Rai shuts down Abhishek Bachchan divorce rumours, wears ‘wedding ring again at Paris fashion week’. Watch
Hindustan Times
SC seeks ED reply on bail to ex-Bengal minister in teachers appointment case
Hindustan Times
EY employee death: Nirmala Sitharaman calls for ‘stress management lessons’; Congress lashes out
Hindustan Times
‘Apologise or…’: Congress challenges Kangana Ranaut to prove her claims against Sonia Gandhi
Hindustan Times
Lindsey Graham says allegations against Mark Robinson are ‘beyond unnerving’
Hindustan Times
Swara Bhasker reveals Fahad Ahmad did not bother to say ‘hi’ when they first met: I was struck that he is not fanboying
Hindustan Times
Angelina Jolie ends two-year-long legal battle with FBI over records about Brad Pitt’s alleged physical abuse
Hindustan Times
In its ruling, the Supreme Court highlighted that the murder trial had seen significant delays due to repeated and unwarranted applications for further investigation, filed at crucial junctures, including just before the final arguments were set to begin.
The initial FIR was lodged on March 31, 2013, and the charge sheet was submitted on July 11 of the same year. However, the trial came to a standstill in 2019 when the first round of applications under Section 311 of the CrPC (for re-examining witnesses) was filed, followed by an application under Section 173(8) in January 2020 for further investigation. Despite the state initially opposing the requests, it later supported the petition for further investigation, causing additional delays, the bench lamented.
Win exciting prizes daily
View T&C
Q. Should India mediate as tensions rise in the Middle East?
Yes
No
The court expressed concern over the impact such delays have on all stakeholders involved. “In spite of eleven years having elapsed after the incident, the trial has still not concluded. The victims of crime, the accused, and society at large have a legitimate expectation that justice will be available within a reasonable time,” stated the bench.
Emphasising that the pursuit of truth must be balanced with the necessity for a swift conclusion to the legal process, the court also took aim at a broader trend in the legal profession some lawyers file applications with no merit, prolonging litigation and adding to the already extensive backlog of cases.
“Reading some of the averments therein, we are left to wonder whether at all the deponents were conscious of what has been written purportedly on their behalf, before appending their signatures. These misadventures directly impinge on the rule of law, because they add to the pendency and the consequential delay in the disposal of other cases which are crying for justice,” it rued.
The bench asserted it is time that “such frivolous and vexatious proceedings are met with due sanctions in the form of exemplary costs to dissuade parties from resorting to such tactics”.
Addressing the issue of further investigation, the apex court clarified that while the power to order additional probe exists, it should be exercised sparingly and only in exceptional circumstances. The court referred to its earlier rulings, noting that further investigations could be ordered if there is credible evidence to suggest that the initial investigation was flawed or incomplete.
However, in this case, the court found no such justification. “The high court gave no valid reason for ordering a further investigation, and the applications rehashed previously rejected grounds, contributing to unnecessary delays,” it held, setting aside the April 2021 order of the Madurai bench of the Madras high court.
The bench, however, refrained from imposing costs in this particular case due to the high court’s approval of the further investigation, but it made clear that such leniency should not be expected in future cases.
By setting aside the high court’s order and stressing the need for exemplary costs in frivolous cases, the Supreme Court has sounded a caution that parties cannot abuse the legal system for personal gain without risking serious consequences.
Boost your career with IIT Delhi’s Tech & AI Leadership Programme. Enroll Now
Get Current Updates on…
See more
Share this article
Rule Of Law
Supreme Court
by TaboolaPromoted Links
You May Like
Young Millionaire From New Delhi Tells How She Got Rich
Setfieseep
Banks fear this, but they can’t stop you from doing it
JollyHub
‘Vulgar’ dance during Chennai medical conference raises eyebrows, but some say ‘nothing wrong’
Hindustan Times
Next Story
Police ‘not convinced’ by Govinda’s version after questioning in shooting incident but rule out foul play: Report
By
HT Entertainment Desk
| Edited by Abhimanyu Mathur
Oct 02, 2024 04:37 PM IST
Mumbai Police questioned Govinda regarding him accidentally shooting himself with his revolver but are reportedly not convinced with his version of events.
Mumbai Police is currently investigating the incident involving actor Govinda, who sustained leg injuries after his revolver accidentally went off. But the Crime Branch has also launched a parallel enquiry into the incident. Officials of the Crime Branch met the actor at the hospital on Wednesday and as per reports, were not convinced by his version of events. (Also read: Shatrughan Sinha puts to rest conspiracy theories around Govinda’s gunshot injury)
Govinda sustained leg injuries on Tuesday, Oct. 1, 2024, after his revolver accidentally went off at his Mumbai residence. (PTI Photo/Kunal Patil)(PTI)
Govinda sustained leg injuries on Tuesday, Oct. 1, 2024, after his revolver accidentally went off at his Mumbai residence. (PTI Photo/Kunal Patil)(PTI)
Police doubt Govinda’s version of events
News agency PTI has reported that a crime branch team, led by senior police inspector Daya Nayak, visited the hospital on Tuesday and spoke to the actor about the incident. The actor maintains that the gun fell and accidentally discharged a round that hit him in the leg. Govinda was alone when the incident took place at his residence in the early hours of Tuesday.
Get Unlimited access to Hindustan Times E-paper and Archives at 1199/- per year
A News 18 report cited unnamed sources, who said that while the police have ruled out any foul play in the incident, “they are not fully convinced by Govinda’s story”. The report states that they may record Govinda’s statement again. No one has lodged any complaint in this matter so far, police said.
What is Govinda’s version?
The actor has a licensed revolver of Webley company and the bullet hit him near his left knee. A police official told PTI that the revolver, which is an old one, was not locked and misfired, as per the actor.
After the incident, Govinda, who was one of the leading stars of Bollywood in the 90s, issued a statement informing his fans he was doing better.
Read More
Hindustan Times News
Subscribe to our best newsletters
HT Daily Capsule
Sign Up to Subscribe
fb-logo
in-logo
instagram
new-tw
Latest News World News India News Cricket Live Score Cricket Schedule T20 World Cup Suryakumar Yadav Virat Kohli Yashasvi Jaiswal Axar Patel Hardik Pandya Ravindra Jadeja Shivam Dube Rishabh Pant Sanju Samson Arshdeep Singh Jasprit Bumrah Kuldeep Yadav Mohammed Siraj Yuzvendra Chahal Tim David David Warner Cameron Green Travis Head India vs Sri Lanka India vs South Africa India vs Pakistan India vs Netherlands India vs Ireland India vs England India vs Bangladesh India vs Australia India vs Afghanistan CITY NEWS Bengaluru News Bhopal News Chandigarh News Chennai News Dehradun News Delhi News Gurugram News Hyderabad News Indore News Jaipur News Kolkata News Lucknow News Mumbai News Noida News Patna News Pune News Ranchi News Other Cities Entertainment Bollywood News Hollywood News Music Tamil Cinema Telugu Cinema TV Web Series Entertainment Others Books HT Insight Brand Post Brand Stories Elections Upcoming Elections Income Tax Calculator ASTROLOGY Horoscope Education Admission News Board Exams Competitive Exams Employment News Exam Results Education News LIFESTYLE Art and Culture Brunch Fashion Festivals Health Recipes Relationship Travel Pet Web Stories Trending Business Photos Videos Environment Science Opinion Editorials Car and Bike Technology Sports Badminton Football Hockey Tennis Others Quickreads Covid 19 Assembly Election GAMES Daily Sudoku Daily Crossword Daily Word Jumble TRENDING NEWS Yashasvi Jaiswal India vs Bangladesh LIVE J&K Election LIVE Israel Lebanon War LIVE US Presidential Election 2024 Assembly Election 2024 Cricket Score LIVE Cricket Schedule World News Govinda TRENDING TOPICS Israel LIVE Updates India vs Bangladesh LIVE Yashasvi Jaiswal J&K Election LIVE US Election 2024 Assembly Election 2024 Cricket Cricket Match Today India News World News US News Thar Roxx Price Govinda Mahindra Thar
Latest India News
Antony Blinken meets S Jaishankar, says India-US working to address ‘global challenges’
Who was Garcia Glenn White? Texas executes man, 61, for brutal 1989 murders of twin teen sisters
Atlanta rapper Rich Homie Quan died from an accidental drug overdose, medical examiner says
Texas man executed for 1989 murders of twin sisters
In India, warming climate pressures scientists to keep developing tougher seeds
Triptii Dimri talks about coping with growing attention: ‘I’m not free anymore. Sense of freedom has gone away’
Latest trending News, Live Updates Today October 2, 2024: Caught on cam: Brave woman single-handedly stops robbery, protects her house against 3 people in Amritsar
Caught on cam: Brave woman single-handedly stops robbery, protects her house against 3 people in Amritsar
Rescuers scour North Carolina mountains for survivors cut off by Hurricane Helene
Forget Bazball, Ashwin hints at ‘Gamball’ after India shatter world records to beat Bangladesh in 5 sessions
About Us Contact us Terms of use Privacy policy Weather Today HT Newsletters Subscription Disclaimer Print Ad Rates Code of Ethics Site Map RSS Feeds
mint-logo HH-logo mint-lounge HT_Auto ht-tech ht-bangla healthshots OTT-icons slurrp-icon smartcast-logo ht-kannada ht-tamil ht-telegu ht-marathi Instore Radio – FAB Play vc-circle tech-circle vcc-edge
