The Indian Express
Journalism of Courage
Subscribe
Sign In
Home
ePaper
My Express
UPSC
India
Explained
Opinion
Politics
Business
Entertainment
Sports
Chennai
Lifestyle
Tech
Education
Research
Videos
UPSC Pack
Express Shorts
Mini Crossword
Premium
🎙️ Podcast
Health & Wellness
In focus
NewsOpinionColumnsSupreme Court frees Arvind Kejriwal, but ties his hands
Supreme Court frees Arvind Kejriwal, but ties his hands
Bail conditions on the Delhi Chief Minister curtails the Delhi voters’ mandate, reduces him to a figurehead. It also goes against the spirit of the principle that bail and not jail should be the rule
Written by Rekha Sharma
Updated: September 15, 2024 13:34 ISTNewsguard
clock_logo4 min read
facebook
twitter
whatsapp
Reddit
1
Arvind Kejriwal
Supreme Court granted bail to Delhi Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal on Friday. (PTI photo)
Advertisement
After much shuttling between the trial court, Delhi High Court and the Supreme Court, Delhi Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal has finally got bail after an apex court order of August 13. What is of significance is the difference of opinion between the two judges on the bench on the bail conditions imposed on him.
Earlier, another two-judge bench of the Supreme Court had granted bail to Kejriwal in a money laundering case registered against him by the Enforcement Directorate. The bail order, however, imposed several conditions on him. Two of those have become quite controversial. The first is that he shall neither visit the office of the Chief Minister nor the Delhi Secretariat, while the second is that he shall not sign official files “unless it is required and necessary for obtaining clearance/approval of the Lieutenant Governor”. While Justice Surya Kant, the presiding judge did not find anything wrong in these conditions and accordingly applied them mutatis mutandis to the order passed on August 13, Justice Ujjal Bhuyan expressed his strong reservations.
Advertisement
However, he has not dissented because of respect towards what he has called “judicial discipline and propriety”, since those conditions were imposed by another two-judge bench.
short article insertThe effect of the order is that Kejriwal cannot visit the Chief Minister’s office or the Delhi Secretariat, he cannot hold meetings in his office, cannot pass orders in writing and cannot even sign official files. In other words, though elected by citizens as a member of the legislature, he cannot effectively act as Chief Minister. However, what prevents him from holding meetings at his residence and taking decisions? And what if these decisions are orally communicated to the Chief Secretary but are not carried out because the officials claim that these do not have proper sanction? What kind of governance would that be?
Advertisement
The order does not deprive Kejriwal of the Chief Minister’s office but does not allow him to act as per the oath he had taken on assuming that position. He can go to Haryana and canvass for his party, ask the voters there to exercise their constitutional right, elect the government of their choice, and yet his hands are tied in acting as a Chief Minister in Delhi. The order curtails the mandate delivered by the voters of Delhi which requires Kejriwal to act, and act effectively as the elected member of the Legislative Assembly and as the elected Chief Minister of Delhi. It thus negates the mandate of the people of Delhi and hurts their constitutional right to elect an active working Chief Minister – not a figurehead.
Festive offer
Recently, the Supreme Court was informed that the decision on the remission of prisoners was getting delayed because the relevant papers did not have the Chief Minister’s signatures. In cases like these, who are the real sufferers? Obviously, those languishing in jail.
Advertisement
Though Justice Bhuyan has disagreed with the two conditions of bail imposed on Kejriwal, he has felt compelled to follow the view taken in the earlier judgment of a co-ordinant bench. It appears that had Justice Bhuyan not agreed with his brother judge, Kejriwal, perhaps, would have had to remain longer in jail because, in that event, the matter would have gone to the Chief Justice for constituting a larger bench. However, Justice Bhuyan’s predicament raises a larger question. Is judicial discipline a more compelling reason than the rights conferred constitutionally? Law evolves, develops, and grows. It should never be unimaginative in the name of consistency or so-called judicial propriety.
Law is no more the arbitrary command of a sovereign. Each order of the court must be a fertile field for the evolution and progress of the Rule of Law and proper administration of justice. The conditions neither safeguard the citizen who elected the CM nor advance their political rights. It not only defeats a citizen’s legitimate aspiration to have a working representative but also defeats the spirit of the now well-accepted principle of law that bail and not jail should be the rule.
Judges need to remember what Elbert Hubbard wrote in Epigrams: “God will not look you over for medals, degrees or diplomas, but for scars”.
The writer is a former judge of the Delhi High Court
© The Indian Express Pvt Ltd
First uploaded on: 15-09-2024 at 13:33 IST
Tags:
AAP
Arvind Kejriwal
UPSC Pack
Tavleen Singh writesWhy Rahul Gandhi needs an education
X
Latest News
Sections
Latest
Latest
Explained
Explained
Shorts
Shorts
New
Premium
Premium
ExamAlert+
ExamAlert+
Audio
Audio
Newsletters
ePaper
Share Icon
Join Channel
Video
Video
App
App
Newsletter
Newsletter
Next Story
Top Categories
Explained News
Political Pulse
Latest Opinion
Mumbai News
Delhi News
Pune News
Bangalore News
Bollywood News
Health News
India News
Sports News
Lifestyle News
Latest News
Cricket
Tech Reviews
Gadgets
Mobile & Tabs
Food & Wine
Elections 2024
Fitness
Trending News
Latest News
Health and Wellness
Education News
Buy All-Access Plan
Entertainment News
Trending News
Political News
Business News
Why Subscribe Indian Express
Buy Digital Premium
Subscribe To The Indian Express
Indian Express subscription UPSC offer
Income Tax Calculator
Stock Market
iPhone 16
Apple Event 2024
LATEST STORIES
Supreme Court frees Arvind Kejriwal, but ties his hands
Nagamangala communal violence: Peace meeting held, Rs 2.5 crore damage reported
Arvind Kejriwal says will resign as Delhi CM in 2 days
Did you know there’s a traditional way to serve and eat the Onam sadya?
UP NEET UG 2024 counselling schedule revised
TMKOC’s Sonu aka Palak Sindhwani reacts to reports of her getting a legal notice from makers for breach of contract: ‘It’s affecting my mental health’
Know Your City: ‘Kumar’ magazine turns 100, how it has contributed to art and literature in Gujarat
Delhi Police arrest man absconding for 2 years after Rs 8-crore ornament heist
Sandeep Reddy Vanga asks Saif Ali Khan if his character dies in Devara Part 1; Jr NTR, Koratala Siva joke about Animal’s runtime. Watch
India Test series provides pathbreaking moment for Bangladesh: The first 150-kph-er in Nahid Rana and Hasan Mahmud, with unique action, raise fast-bowling hopes
What BJP fielding Muslim candidates in past Haryana polls tells us
Chal Kudiye teaser: Diljit Dosanjh encourages Alia Bhatt to rise and fight in Jigra’s new track, fans say ‘A chartbuster loading’
SIIMA Awards 2024: Dasara, Hi Nanna, Kaatera and Sapta Sagaradaache Ello win big on Day 1
Esha Deol says Dharmendra wanted her to ‘settle down at 18’: Challenges women face balancing parental expectations and career goals in India
Hilal Ahmed challenges the narrative on why Muslims have been marginalised in India
Karnataka BJP MLA Munirathna sent to police custody in caste abuse and assault case
Follow Us
Facebook
Twitter
Linkedin
Instagram
Download Apps
Android
iPhone
NewsguardNewsguard
The Indian Express website has been rated GREEN for its credibility and trustworthiness by Newsguard, a global service that rates news sources for their journalistic standards.
Express Group
The Indian Express
ieTamil.com
The Financial Express
ieBangla.com
Loksatta
ieMalayalam.com
Jansatta
ieGujarati.com
inUth
IE Education
The ExpressGroup
MyInsuranceClub
Newsletters
26/11 Stories of Strength
Ramnath Goenka Excellence in Journalism Awards
Online Classes for Kids
Light House Journalism
Compare Term Insurance
Quick Links
T&C
Privacy Policy
Advertise with Us
Brand Solutions
Contact Us
Subscribe
Statutory provisions on reporting (sexual offenses)
This website follows the DNPA’s code of conduct
CSR
Copyright © 2024 The Indian Express [P] Ltd. All Rights Reserved
Powered by WordPress.com VIP
