Gutka in TN assembly: HC restarts hearing on notices to DMK MLAs


Gutka in TN assembly: HC restarts hearing on notices to DMK MLAs

Chennai: After a lull of three years, the Madras high court has recommenced hearing on pleas of 21 DMK MLAs, including party president M K Stalin, challenging a privilege motion against them for waving gutka packets in the Tamil Nadu assembly.
The first bench comprising Chief Justice A P Sahi and Justice Senthikumar Ramamoorthy has allotted three days (Wednesday to Friday) exclusively for hearing the case.


On Wednesday, senior advocate for the DMK R Shanmugasundaram commenced his arguments saying, “We have objection for deputy speaker Pollachi V Jayaraman chairing the privileges committee of the Tamil Nadu assembly as he has recently moved a civil suit for damages against Stalin in connection with the Pollachi sexual assault case.”

He also said two of the 21 DMK legislators, J Anbazhagan and KPP Samy, had died during the pendency of the pleas and sought that their petitions may be removed.
“Similarly, Thousand Lights legislator K K Selvam has switched sides and therefore we are not representing him. We have no objections for him to have a separate counsel of his choice,” the senior advocate said.As to the challenge made against the showcause notices issued by the privilege committee against the 21 MLAs, senior counsel said the Food Safety Act, under which the notices had been issued, did not prohibit possession nor exhibiting of gutka packets or its pictures.


Your one-minute Citynews catch up

As China factor looms, India hopes to work with Lanka’s Rajapaksas

While China may be in the pole position in Sri Lanka with the Rajapaksas in the saddle again, India seems confident that its outreach to PM Rajapaksa when will ensure the island neighbour doesn’t return to its pre-2015 pivot to Beijing. India sees itself as having played a major role in improving the lives of Sri Lankan people in past few years with focus on connectivity & housing.

Karnataka govt will deal with rioters with iron hand: Minister

Terming the violence in the city as a ‘well planned act,’ Karnataka revenue minister R Ashoka on Wednesday said the ‘traitors,’ who perpetrated the riots would be dealt with an iron hand and steps would be taken to ensure that such incidents do not recur. Ashoka said, “The manner in which the riots were perpetrated shows that it was a well planned act.”

Don’t let former players’ experience go waste: Dravid tells state units

Use the expertise of former players as much as possible in the state teams’ cricketing set-up was one of the notable suggestions by NCA head Rahul Dravid while interacting with members of affiliated units during a webinar. The discussions were primarily on various components of fitness data collection and resumption of fitness training in COVID-19 world.

‘Nasty’, ‘Mean’, ‘Horrible’, ‘Disrespectful’: Trump unloads on Kamala

US President Trump led the Republican attack on Democratic vice-presidential nominee Kamala Harris on Tuesday, calling her “nasty” (repeatedly), “mean,” “horrible” and “disrespectful”. Trump said she was “very very nasty” to Democratic Presidential nominee Joe Biden during the debates, and she was the “meanest, most horrible, most disrespectful of anyone in the US Senate”.

Pranab Mukherjee now ‘haemodynamically stable’, says son

Former President Pranab Mukherjee, who is on ventilator support after a brain surgery is now “haemodynamically stable”, his son Abhijit Mukherjee said on Wednesday. “With All Your Prayers, my father is haemodynamically stable now. I request everyone to continue with your prayers & good wishes for his speedy recovery. Thank You,” tweeted Abhijit.

HALs Light Combat Helicopters deployed for operations at Leh

The Hindustan Aeronautics Limited said on Wednesday two Light Combat Helicopters produced by it have been deployed for operations at high altitude (Leh sector) at short notice to support IAF missions, “in the light of the prevailing situation on border.” “It is the lightest attack helicopter in the world designed and developed by HAL,” HAL’s CMD, R Madhavan, said.


“This apart, the rules of practice of legislators prohibits bringing items like umbrellas and guns inside the House, but not gutka packets. The notice has been issued riddled with gross illegality and in total disregard to the assembly rules,” he argued. Asserting that the court can review the decision of the privilege committee, Shanmugasundaram said, “Judicial review of acts of constitutional authorities are permissible when such acts constitute patent illegalities.”

Continuing the arguments, senior advocate N R Elango said, “When the notices were issued, a minority government was in the rule. Therefore, the actions of the committee were nothing but to strike a balance in the number of legislators in the house.” The actions of the committee must be judged taking into consideration the situation in that point of time. The attempt was clearly to remove 21 MLAs of DMK to match the number, Elango added.
Adding to the arguments on behalf of DMK, advocate Amit Anand Tiwari submitted that once the House viewed an act as a breach of privilege, then the same should be dealt with then and there. In such a situation, the speaker cannot refer the issue to the committee.
Recording the submission, the bench adjourned the hearing to August 13.

You may also like...